Three things in life are a certainty: taxes, death and trains being promised for Christchurch in the lead-up to an election. In 2013 and 2017 Labour promised them. The Greens promise them basically every election. NZ First is jumping on board this election.
I’ve seen a bit of ensuing discussion around it so I thought I’d jot down my thoughts on what the rail landscape looks like from my perspective. Most of this I’ve said before in other posts but I’ll try bring it together in one place.
Passenger rail has existed in Christchurch before. As others have written about, Christchurch used to have heavy rail services connecting it to satellite towns and the wider district, and trams proving urban transport. The last tram was pulled out in the 1950s and the last passenger service in the 1970s, with the exception of a handful of tourist-targeted services.
There have been several technical reports published since, looking at the feasibility of bringing them back: 2014, 2017, 2020, 2023. The salient points from these, in my view, are:
- You can get a bare bones rail service up and running relatively cheaply and easily, using existing facilities. This was proven recently by the private enterpise “Crusaders Express”.
- Although inexpensive, this service would be crappy. Passengers would have to board using ramps as there aren’t operational stations anymore. It would be low frequency, have few stations, and would not service the highest demand areas e.g. the central city. As such, it most likely wouldn’t attract huge ridership.
- There are ways to improve this, but unfortunately they are not that cheap or easy. To get a really useful service that would carry high volumes of people such that it would have a material benefit for the city, it would need:
- Higher frequencies. This means we’d need to double-track the northern line. There is mostly space to do this if we remove the railway cycleway, although there are some pinch points e.g. the recently built Mitre10 Mega. It would also need a new Waimakariri bridge.
- More stations. There’s only one operational station on the line, at Addington. There are a few mothballed stations we could probably fix up without too much cost e.g. Rolleston, Rangiora, Papanui. In some locations we’d need to build brand new ones, e.g. Hornby and Kaiapoi. These would be more costly and difficult.
- Central city station. The biggest problem with heavy rail in Christchurch has always been that it doesn’t get into the central city. It skirts around the outside, roughly 1.0-1.5km from the destinations most people would be going to. The 2023 business case looked at extending the railway line into the central city along Riccarton Avenue in a trench. This greatly increases the usefulness of the service, but also the cost.

These issues are all part of the reason that the 2023 MRT business case recommended that the Greater Christchurch partners (NZTA, CCC, ECan, SDC and WDC) focus on a street-running system along Riccarton and Papanui Roads. It’s a lot easier to get it right into the central city, and is a better option if the goal is to service the most urbanised areas like Riccarton, University, Merivale and Papanui.
The business case also considered doing both street-running and heavy rail at the same time: a high-frequency, high-volume street-running service between Hornby and Belfast, complemented by a minimalist commuter heavy rail service to the satellite towns Rolleston, Kaiapoi and Rangiora. This stacked up somewhat respectfully with a benefit cost ratio of 1.1 – not huge, yet higher than most of the big roads the government are currently trying to build. The idea was that central city passengers would transfer at a specially-built Riccarton station onto the street-running MRT for the last km into town. This transfer point would also be handy for people heading west to the university or airport.

I always thought this option had merit from a transport planning point of view – plenty of other cities follow this kind of 2-rail solution. I think it was discounted mostly from a pragmatic point of view – getting one form of rail off the ground is going to be hard enough for the city’s leaders, let alone two.
I don’t think heavy rail is a dumb idea, but if we do end up pursuing it I think we need to do it properly. I’d hate for us to trial a bare bones rail service, have no one use it because it’s too crappy, then have rail dismissed as uneconomic for the next 30 years. We need to actually spend some money to get proper stations up and running, and we need to decide what we’re doing in the central city. I’m not sure of the best solution but I think one thing is clear – a Moorhouse Ave station can’t be the long-term plan to service the central city.
That’s how I see it anyway: I know others have differrent views. Let’s see what happens in a couple of weeks time!
I have a few thoughts / bits of context to add to the discourse:
In short, I don’t think we have wildly different views. I agree that it needs to be done properly, but I probably think ‘properly’ should be a slightly lower bar.
LikeLike
I was just looking back at your 2019 blog.
Christchurch Rapid Transit: a Proposal for Rail – TALKING TRANSPORT
Do you still reckon that should be the long-term option the city pursues? It’s not massively different to Option 1c above – the Moorhouse Ave station is the main point of difference.
You should write a blog on what a “bare bones” trial needs to look like.
LikeLike
It’s weird reading that blog back now because I’m actually surprised how much I still agree with my younger self.
I think any heavy rail service that doesn’t terminate as close to the city as possible is going to face backlash from day one. That’s probably where my thinking has most changed.
If I can find the time I’d be happy to put a blog post together.
LikeLike
Hi Chris,
Central Railway station
LikeLike
The first decision is to scrap Addington it is NOT in a central location. Build Moorhouse again
LikeLike
Yea I don’t think Addington would be of too much use for a commuter rail station – the Crusaders Express didn’t entertain that idea for very long. Need something closer.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Agreed Chris. Railways Dept got it right first time. A new central station off Morehouse is best option.
LikeLike
Interesting analysis. Looking forward to a followup after today’s announcement.
LikeLike
I don’t think that the Northern Line needs to be double-tracked for an hourly service, which would be enough initially. However, it would need at the very least a double-tracked station in Kaiapoi, with Belfast also providing a crossing for freight trains, the Coastal Pacific and any heavily delayed trains. In addition, basic stations would be required in Kaiapoi, Belfast, and Riccarton. Papanui would need to be upgraded (and the platform height increased).
On the Main South Line, double tracking would ideally be reinstated between Islington and Rolleston, with new stations in Templeton, Hornby (behind The Hub), and Moorhouse.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yae true. Looking again at the snip from the business case it says 30 minute frequencies were assumed to be possible without double-tracking the northern line, instead upgrading the signalling system and building passing loops at stations.
Maybe that’s enough, even in the long-term. Although 30 minutes isn’t “high-frequency” it would still provide a pretty decent level of service for Christchurch.
LikeLike
30 min frequencies are ok for a trial but long term needs to be around 15 or less during peak hour hence double tracking required. Any frequency above zero has to be good for Christchurch.
Question – will the corridor to Lincoln be reestablished for access to the university ?
LikeLike
PS I’d be interested in your more extended thoughts on all this if you wanted to write a post:)
LikeLike
Hi Chris. Sorry to busy write a post.
A new Central station at Morehouse Road will need to connect with an LRT that connects to the bus interchange & stadium
LikeLike
Hi Tim.
Another consideration is re-establishing the rail curve around Blenheim Road, into Moorhouse Street. Long-term, this is required for trains coming from Rangiora. Ultimately a new ‘central ‘ station needs to be constructed. Addington maybe kept for Tourist trains similar to Parklands in Adelaide Aust.
LikeLike